Introduction
Of particular interest is that the in situ Cairo tiling is only one member of a broader family of "Cairo-like" tilings. Under the same general conditions, the pentagon may vary continuously, or even degenerate, from a square to a rectangle, the latter appearing as a basketweave configuration. The resulting range naturally suggests a spectrum extending from minima to maxima.
An examination of the literature is illuminating in how little this has been studied, for what may appear to be an obvious concept. Depending on interpretation, there are only two or three such studies. Herbert C. Moore, in his 1909 patent “Tile”, appears to imply, in diagrammatic form, a rudimentary sequence, although this is far from ideal. This property was first set out explicitly by Donald G. Wood in 1968 (Figure 1), and later discussed in a different form by Robert Macmillan in 1979 through his five "special cases". Wood's treatment is by far the clearest, presenting what appears to be a deliberate sequence of five "balanced" diagrams, from a square to a double basketweave tiling in successive stages. Macmillan's treatment is less explicit and does not present a comparable sequence. Instead, it establishes the underlying principle through examples of particular interest, notably the in situ pentagon with its collinearity properties, the equilateral pentagon, and the pentagon corresponding to the dual of the semiregular 3.3.4.3.4 tiling. These can reasonably be regarded as the principal special cases in the sequence. Perhaps somewhat surprisingly, I do not know of any other such studies. However, none of these studies considers a systematic sequence of angle increments.
An obvious next step, at least to me, is to show the full range of transition from the square to the basketweave tiling. I do this at ½° increments, first as an abstract study listing the angles, with a set of 91, and then partially pictorially, showing the more interesting instances with aesthetic properties and vertex alignment (Figure 2). Note that neither the equilateral pentagon nor the in situ pentagon is obtained by this procedure. Drawing a complete set of diagrams of all possibilities would be time-consuming, even if reduced to whole-degree increments, but I still baulk at such a compromise.
I should add that there are other sequences, previously examined, that have been omitted from this update. However, some hovered between a somewhat "stuttered" sequence and methods of composing a Cairo tiling. Upon reflection, I considered these confused the premise and cluttered the page, and so have made the one obvious angle-increment minima-to-maxima study the main focus. The omitted material can be found on the Wayback Machine version of the same page, some of which will be revived later in a separate study devoted to different ways of composing a Cairo tiling.
The resulting table also invites the search for local and global patterns. For example, the Cordovan pentagon occupies a central position in the sequence at entry 46 and may therefore be regarded as a particularly representative member. The dual of the 3.3.4.3.4 tiling appears at entry 61. This immediately raises an intriguing question: does entry 31, located symmetrically on the opposite side of the same dividing line, possess any comparable significance that has thus far gone unnoticed? It may be no more than coincidence, but the possibility is sufficiently suggestive to merit attention. The form does exhibit a noteworthy vertex alignment, and I have provisionally referred to it as the "Bailey Pentagon".
Despite these difficulties, the study addresses a subject that has received remarkably little attention. The minima-to-maxima perspective has largely been overlooked. Whatever its shortcomings, the present work represents an attempt to address that gap.
Figure 1. Donald Wood, 1968
Cairo Tilings Formed by ½° Incremental Angles
* LB, SS = Long Base, Short Sides; SB, LS = Short Base, Long Sides
91 cases are given, of which most are not particularly of any 'special interest', being a generic Cairo tiling with standard features of overlapping pentagons in hexagons at right angles to each other. However, that said, a few are indeed of special interest, which I illustrate below. Specifically, in sequence:
(i) No. 1, where the tiling degenerates to a rectangle in a double basketweave arrangement.
(ii) No. 31, an alignment on a vertex feature.
(iii) No. 46, an alignment on a vertex feature.
(iv) No. 61, the dual of the semi-regular 3.3.4.3.4 tiling.
(v) No. 91, where the tiling degenerates to a square.
Interestingly, Robert Macmillan also implied his own "special interest" list, but seemingly failed to notice Nos. 31 and 46, both possessing features of alignment.
Special cases, as outlined in the comments, from minima to maxima
Fig. 2a. No. 1, Rectangles, in a double basketweave
Fig. 2b. No. 31, Bailey Pentagon
Fig. 2c. No. 46, Cordovan pentagon
Fig. 2d. No. 61, Dual of 3.3.4.3.4
Fig. 2e. No. 91, Squares
References
Herbert C. Moore. “Tile”. United States Patent 928,320, 20 July 1909.
Donald G. Wood. Space Enclosure Systems. Bulletin 205, November 1968.
Robert H. Macmillan. “Pyramids and pavements: some thoughts from Cairo”, The Mathematical Gazette, 1979, pp. 251–255.
Page History
2–4 November 2026. Drastically revised and shortened the page, as the previous version had expanded, albeit in good faith, from the original minima-to-maxima premise and had become unnecessarily convoluted. The principal study of ½° angle increments has been retained, with the accompanying text having been extensively rewritten. All else has been deleted. Since the original writing in 2020, I have also found, in August 2026, what is, to my knowledge, the clearest illustration of the premise, by Donald Wood, and so this is now included.
8 April 2026. Started to remove tables and replace with Sheets (newly learned), as pushed by Google. Tables are no longer supported upon the conversion, with large spaces at the end, resulting in a poor presentation.
8 July 2025. Reappraisal from Classic Sites.
The conversion had left the page in an imperfect state, in many ways, not to mention my own inadequacies of the day in terms of presentation, albeit the idea is of undoubted interest and is fundamentally sound.
The conversion had left the tables with large open spaces at the foot, resulting in a poor presentation for the viewer. However, it is possible to overcome this by scrolling up, to better fit the text, which I did. Or at least I thought it would! When the page was published, the wide spaces remained! A major obstacle is that tables are no longer supported in New Sites. No editing is possible. Also, pictures were side by side with the text on occasion, with captions 'free floating', resulting in a disjoint appearance. This I correct.
As for my own shortcomings, the content itself was also unsatisfactorily presented. Upon the return, I had found an 'under construction' notice. Seemingly, I had become exasperated with the study, with the intention of returning, but never did. I removed a mooted 'Method 6', 'Cairo Tilings by Projection - Two Variations', in the 'overview', these not appearing on the page. I am not entirely convinced by the title. Perhaps 'Variations in Composing' would be better. Typos were corrected in Grammarly, pending a more extensive grammar analysis at a later date. In the references, I replaced hyphens with dashes.
The content is decidedly 'awkward', and requires another reading at a later date to be better presented.
Page Created 30 June 2020. Last Updated 2 July 2020. 15–16 July added illustrations