Introduction
As can be seen from the various studies presented on the Cairo tiling pages, there exists a wide range of examples that may be described, in a loose sense, as "Cairo-like". In particular, the pages Defining a Cairo Tiling and Minima to Maxima demonstrate how these forms can range from a "near square" to a "near rectangle", the latter occurring in a double basketweave configuration.
However, these examples vary considerably in aesthetic appeal and mathematical interest. A few possess particularly attractive visual qualities, whilst others stand out because of distinctive mathematical properties. This page brings together five such examples and examines the features that make them noteworthy. Broadly speaking, two tiers may be discerned, which, for the sake of general order, are described here as the "high" and "low" tiers.
High Tier (Three examples of broad equal status)
1. In Situ (108°43′, 90°, 143°13′)
Fig. 1
Aesthetically, the in situ pentagon is especially appealing and may reasonably be regarded with one of the three claims as to the finest pentagon in the series.
Its principal strength lies in its line of collinearity, alone among the pentagon claimants, which gives an appealing unifying effect on the eye, which can follow the “continuation”. Against this, however, it lacks the pleasing features of an equilateral pentagon, and the composition of the dual.
Paradoxically, despite the in situ model determining the “defining” Cairo tiling, it is invariably not described as such in the literature, with only Macmillan stating the true geometry!
My assessment is that, aesthetically, along with the equilateral pentagon and dual, it is one of the three higher-tier examples.
2. Equilateral Pentagon (114°18′, 90°, 131°24′)
Fig. 2
Aesthetically this is very pleasing indeed, and arguably this is the ‘best’ pentagon in the series, not only here of the 1 pentagon category but the series as a whole, in that it is the most ‘basic’ of all the pentagon types, in that it possesses the most symmetry, namely of all five sides the same length, of which I consider the overriding issue as regards aesthetics. (The other examples in the series here can be described, at least in comparison, as weaker, with different side lengths.) Indeed, this is my personal favourite. Such aesthetics probably account for its popularity as the frequently stated serving model, likely from Gardner’s account (MacMahon also gives this). However, it does possess one relative shortcoming, in that it does not possess collinearity with others, namely.
Also, to me at least, (but of very much of minor importance), is that upon a ‘broad, casual glance’, it has the pleasing appearance of a ‘faux’ regular pentagon tiling, despite this being known not to tile.
3. Dual of the 3.3.4.3.4 Tiling (120°, 90°)
Fig. 3
Aesthetically, the dual pentagon is especially appealing and may reasonably be regarded as one of the three claims as to the finest pentagon in the series.
Much of its appeal derives from its underlying provenance as the dual of the semi-regular 3.3.4.3.4 tiling. Furthermore, it possesses a particularly attractive set of interior angles, namely two angles of 90° and three of 120°, giving rise to a pleasing collection of round-number values not found in the other principal examples. Another factor in its favour is that it occupies an interesting geometric position, being an “average” pentagon that lies midway between Macmillan’s minimum (rectangle) and maximum (square) conditions.
Its principal weakness, when compared with the equilateral pentagon, is that its sides are not all of equal length. Like the equilateral pentagon, it also lacks collinearity.
Despite these limitations, its combination of geometric pedigree and attractive angle structure may help to explain why many authors have adopted it as a representative example of the Cairo pentagon.
Nevertheless, whilst I regard it as one of the higher-tier examples in the series, I would still place it slightly behind the equilateral pentagon and in situ in overall aesthetic appeal.
Low Tier (Two examples of broad equal status)
4. Cordovan Pentagon (112.5°, 90°, 135°)
Fig. 4
Aesthetically, this is a pleasing pentagon whose principal attraction lies in its vertex alignment feature. When the relevant sides are extended, they intersect the nearest vertex of a neighbouring pentagon, giving rise to an elegant and distinctive geometric relationship.
Its principal weakness is that, despite possessing alignment, I consider this form to be far less compelling than the collinearity exhibited by the in situ model. Whilst attractive in its own right, it falls short of what I regard as the strongest manifestation of the collinearity of a line as against passing through a point, as here.
Despite its noteworthy characteristics, this pentagon appears to have attracted little attention in the literature. Indeed, it seems that only Antonia Redondo Buitrago and Encarnación Reyes Iglesias have discussed it, doing so in the context of their studies of the Cordovan proportion, from which the title derives.
My assessment is that aesthetically, it is of a lower tier than the three favoured instances.
5. Bailey Pentagon (105°, 90°, 150°)
Fig. 5
Simply stated, this mostly repeats the points made with the Cordovan pentagon. Aesthetically, this is a pleasing pentagon whose principal attraction lies in its vertex alignment feature. When the relevant sides are extended, they intersect the nearest vertex of a neighbouring pentagon, giving rise to an elegant and distinctive geometric relationship.
Its principal weakness is that, despite possessing alignment, I consider this form to be less compelling than the collinearity exhibited by the in situ model. Whilst attractive in its own right, it falls short of what I regard as the strongest manifestation of the collinearity of a line as against passing through a point, as here.
Despite its relatively noteworthy characteristics, this pentagon appears to have attracted little attention in the literature. Indeed, it seems that save for a Wikipedia page, as part of a sequence, it is not recognised. As I was the first to notice this feature, I thus took it upon myself to name it accordingly.
My assessment is that aesthetically, along with the related Corovan pentagon, it is of a far lower tier than the three favoured instances.
Summary
Of the five candidates for the title of the most aesthetic Cairo pentagon, three occupy what I regard as the higher tier. Among these, I have a slight but definite preference for the equilateral model, followed by the in situ model and then the dual of the 3.3.4.3.4 tiling. Put simply, I consider the advantage of having all sides equal to outweigh the collinearity feature, which in turn outweighs the geometric pedigree of the dual. Nevertheless, all three are appealing in their own way, and any of them would be a worthy representative of the Cairo pentagon. All stand clearly above a generic Cairo tile.
The two alignment models form the lower tier and are broadly comparable in aesthetic appeal. If a distinction is to be made, the Cordovan Pentagon might be regarded as marginally superior to the Bailey Pentagon, as its alignment lies closer to the given pentagon. However, the difference is slight, and the two examples are largely on a par.
References (model order as of my listing above)
Robert H. Macmillan, “Pyramids and pavements: some thoughts from Cairo”, The Mathematical Gazette, December 1979, pp. 251–255.
(Gives the collinearity in situ model)
James Dunn, “Tessellations with Pentagons”, The Mathematical Gazette, 1971, pp. 336–369.
(Gives the equilateral model)
Martin Gardner, “On tessellating the plane with convex polygon tiles”, Scientific American, 1975, pp. 112–117.
(Gives the equilateral model, derived from Dunn)
Doris Schattschneider, “Tiling the Plane with Congruent Pentagons”, Mathematics Magazine, 1978, pp. 29–44.
(Gives the dual of the 3.3.4.3.4 tiling model)
Antonia Redondo Buitrago and Encarnación Reyes Iglesias. “The Geometry of the Cordovan Polygons”, Visual Mathematics 2008b 10, 4.
(Gives the Cordovan model)
Page History
9–12 November 2026. A general tidy-up, revision and enlargement, with the page presentation remaining broadly the same. No change was made to the imagery. Major changes include a four-point structure for each entry: Principal strengths, Principal weaknesses, Historical popularity, Personal assessment. Removed occasional outdated text. Corrected angle notation. Added a Summary and References. A full listing is in the working Google Doc.
Although the changes are relatively minor, the page is much the better for it. Copilot and Gemini AI were used for grammar and spell checking.
23 June 2025. Updated from Classic Sites. A general tidying up, with minor corrections in the text and formatting caused by the conversion. No material change of note.
1 June 2012. Created